Question 1 · Surgery, Clinical
A 74-year-old man taking aspirin has had 8 hours of sudden epigastric pain and now has generalised tenderness with guarding. Pulse is 104 per minute, temperature 37.6 C, white cell count 15 x 10^9/L, and lipase is normal. An erect chest radiograph shows no gas under either hemidiaphragm. What is the most appropriate next investigation?
- A. Abdominal ultrasound of the upper abdomen
- B. Observation with repeat examination in 6 hours
- C. CT of the abdomen and pelvis with IV contrast
- D. Barium meal and follow-through study
- E. Urgent upper gastrointestinal endoscopy
Show the answer and explanation
Answer: C. CT of the abdomen and pelvis with IV contrast
Sudden pain with generalised guarding and leucocytosis in an aspirin user makes perforation likely, and the erect film does not change that: plain films show free gas in only about 30 to 85 percent of perforations, so a negative film never excludes it. CT is the preferred test because it shows small amounts of free gas and fluid and often the site; water-soluble oral contrast can be added if doubt remains. Normal lipase makes pancreatitis less likely.
Why the other options are wrong
- A. Abdominal ultrasound of the upper abdomen: Ultrasound is limited by bowel gas and operator skill and is poor at showing small volumes of free gas, so it would not reliably confirm or exclude perforation here.
- B. Observation with repeat examination in 6 hours: Observation accepts a false negative film; generalised guarding with leucocytosis after sudden pain needs a diagnosis now, and delay worsens outcome after perforation.
- D. Barium meal and follow-through study: Barium leaking through a perforation causes a severe barium peritonitis, so it is avoided whenever perforation is suspected, as it is in this man with peritonism.
- E. Urgent upper gastrointestinal endoscopy: Endoscopy needs air insufflation, which can enlarge a perforation and does not show free gas or fluid; it does not answer the question raised by his peritonism.
Key point: When perforation is suspected but the erect film shows no free gas, proceed to CT of the abdomen, adding water-soluble contrast if needed; never use barium and never accept a negative plain film as exclusion.
References
- Perforated and bleeding peptic ulcer: WSES guidelines, World Journal of Emergency Surgery (WSES), 2020
- Peptic ulcer disease, MSD Manual Professional Edition